Cheap money, or forgiving money?

Over five years and a sale, side by side. The starting figures are a food maker's second line, so swap in your own.

Starting figures · add your own
The money and the business

The same sum either way.

From your accounts, before any interest is paid.

Your own figure. We don't value businesses, and the one in the box is a placeholder, not a guess at yours.

So £400,000 buys 25% of the business on your figure.

Your guess. The same in both, because it's the same plan.

The loan

Repaid monthly, in equal amounts of interest and capital.

The bad year

Yours to set. Think of the worst year you've had, then a bit worse.

Also counted: £50,000 a year on kit to stand still, £100,000 of tax and what the owners take, and a mix of half borrowed, half from a share.

about 8% fall a year
Where the share stops being the dearer money
17%
The fall in profit that leaves the loan short in year one

You'd keep 75% on the share, 85.7% on the mix, all of it on the loan.

What the numbers sayThe loan is short in your bad year

Three ways, side by side

Borrowed, the money takes back £486,600; half and half, £801,000; from a share, £986,800. In year one in your bad year, the loan leaves £22,300 short, the mix £26,300, the share £75,000.

Or a bit of both

Every mix from all borrowed to all from a share. All borrowed costs £86,600 and leaves £22,300 short in your bad year; your mix, half and half, costs £401,000 and leaves £26,300; all from a share costs £586,800 and leaves £75,000. Borrowing up to 75% of it gets through your bad year; more than that is short.

When does the share cost more?

Each way's cost over five years and a sale as profit runs from a 20% fall to 20% growth a year. At your growth, up 10%, all borrowed costs £86,600, half and half £401,000 and all from a share £586,800. They cost the same, £86,600 either way, at a fall of about 8% a year; with more growth than that, the share costs more.

On your figures, over five years and a sale, borrowing the £400,000 costs £86,600 in interest, and selling 25% for it hands the new shareholder £986,800, £586,800 more than it brought in. The share is the dearer money unless profit falls by about 8% a year or more. In year one the loan costs £97,300 in repayments whatever happens: profit can fall 17% before they outrun the cash left. In your bad year (profit down 25%) the loan leaves you £22,300 short where the share leaves £75,000, because nothing has to go to a shareholder. Half and half costs £401,000, sells 14.3% and leaves £26,300 in the bad year.

Three ways to find £400,000. Over five years and a sale, at 10% growth a year
Each wayAll borrowedHalf and halfAll from a share
Borrowed£400,000£200,000£0
From a share£0£200,000£400,000
Share sold0%14.3%25%
Share you keep100%85.7%75%
Repayments a year (fixed)£97,300£48,700£0
Interest over five years£86,600£43,300£0
The shareholder's part of five years' profit£0£281,600£503,700
The shareholder's part of your figure at year five£0£276,100£483,200
Cost over five years and a sale£86,600£401,000£586,800
Yours over five years and a sale£3,460,700£3,146,300£2,960,500
Year one, normal year: cash left£52,700£101,300£150,000
Year one, your bad year: cash left£22,300 short£26,300£75,000
Profit can fall before the cash runs out17%33%50% no repayments
What each costs, by profit growth. Cost over five years and a sale, to the nearest £100
Profit a yearAll borrowedHalf and halfAll from a share
Down 10%£86,600£96,300£53,600
Down 5%£86,600£154,000£154,500
Flat£86,600£222,800£275,000
Up 5%£86,600£304,600£418,000
Up 10%£86,600£401,000£586,800
Up 15%£86,600£514,200£784,900
Up 20%£86,600£646,400£1,016,200

Rough sums on your figures, before tax and fees. Not financial or investment advice, not a valuation, and not a view on whether to borrow or sell a share, how much, or to or from whom. The figure for what the business is worth is yours. Everything runs in your browser.

Downloads propellr-funding-reminder.ics. Opens in Outlook, Google or Apple calendars. No sign-up, no email.

How this works

It takes the same sum two ways, and a mix of both, and follows each over five years of profit at the growth you expect, then a sale, or a value put on it, at year five.

A loan takes back what you borrowed plus interest. A share takes its part of every year's profit, paid out or kept, and its part of the value at the end. The share it buys is the money divided by your figure plus the money, because the money goes into the business.

Your figure for what the business is worth is yours. We don't value businesses. At year five it moves in step with profit, so if profit doubles, so does your figure.

Then year one, twice: a normal year and your bad year. Repayments go out whatever happens. A shareholder's part goes out only when you choose to pay one.

What a share carries besides money, a say in decisions and in any sale, is set in the paperwork between you, and that's a conversation for a lawyer, not a calculator.

Share sold = money from a share ÷ (your figure + money from a share)
Cost of a share = share × (five years' profit + your figure at year five) − the money
Cost of a loan = interest over five years

The share a sum buys, on your own figure for the business before the money, to the nearest 1%
Your figure£100,000£250,000£400,000£1,000,000
£500,00017%33%44%67%
£1,000,0009%20%29%50%
£2,000,0005%11%17%33%
£4,000,0002%6%9%20%

It leaves out tax, fees, what the money is worth sooner rather than later, and anything the paperwork for a loan or a share would say. Every figure is yours; the sums are ours.

We did one like it

The money · Advise

Whichever way, they'll want the working.

A property developer. The bank wanted more than the budget. We set out the funding need, when the money is needed and how it gets repaid, in one pack with the working behind it.

More on strategic finance

Profitable but short of cash?

Try next

Seen something familiar?

Rough sums only get you so far. Bring the real ones to a first call.

Book a callAsk about this result